Faults and Ideals of
J. R. Miller, 1893
Recently I published a little book bearing the title: "Faults and Ideals
of Young Women." It contained quotations from letters of a number of
young men concerning the points indicated in the title. Many young ladies
have written to the author suggesting that there should be a book bearing on
the "Faults and Ideals of Young Men", and that the young ladies should have
an opportunity to show their opinion. This seemed a fair and proper request,
and this little book is the result.
An old painter of Sienna, after standing for a long time
in silent meditation before his canvas, with hands crossed meekly on his
chest, and head bent reverently low, turned away, saying, "May God
forgive me that I did not do it better!"
Many people, as they come to the close of their life, and
look back at what they have done with their opportunities and privileges,
and at what they are leaving as their finished work, to be their memorial,
can only pray with like sadness, "May God forgive me that I did not do it
If there were some are of getting the benefit of our own
after-thoughts about life as we go along, perhaps most of us would live more
wisely and more beautifully. It is ofttimes said, "If I had my life to live
over again, I would live it differently. I would avoid the mistakes that I
now see I have made. I would not commit the follies and sins which have so
marred my work. I would devote my life with earnestness and intensity to the
achievement and attainment of the best things." No one can get his life back
to live it a second time, but the young have it in their power to live so
that they shall have no occasion to utter such an unavailing wish, when they
reach the end of their life.
We cannot in youth really get the benefit of our own
experience—but we may learn from the experience of others. We may get
lessons from those who have gone over the way before us. We ought to learn
from their mistakes—and to be incited and encouraged by their successes.
Then we may learn even from contemporaries, who have had no more experience
than ourselves. Almost anybody can tell us of quite real faults in our life
and conduct, and point out to us many things in which we may live more
beautifully. If we are wise, we will profit by every such hint. It is in
this line of thought, that these words to young men are prepared. Two
questions were sent to a number of young ladies, requesting answers:
1. What do you consider some of the most common FAULTS of
the young men you have met?
It is not pleasant to stand up to be criticized. No one
likes to be told of his faults. Yet when we think of it, we really ought to
be thankful, for every time we learn of a new fault in ourselves—not because
we have such a fault—but because we have now discovered it. For the
discovery of a fault is to everyone who is living worthily, an opportunity
for fresh conquest, and for a new advance in the growth of a noble
character. To know of a fault in one's self should be instantly to challenge
its continuance. He who consents to keep and cherish in himself a sin or
blemish of which he has become aware, shows a pitiable weakness. He
surrenders part of his life to an enemy, whom he acknowledges he cannot
drive out, and whom he leaves therefore in his stronghold to be a perpetual
menace and peril to him in all the future. He permits a flaw to remain in
his character, building it into the heart of the structure and leaving it
there, not only to be a blemish—but to be also a point of weakness, at
which, some time, in great stress, his life may break and fall.
Perfection is the aim of all true manhood. There is an
ideal ever unattained, yet never lost sight of, which shines continually
before the earnest soul, calling it ever upward toward spotless divine
beauty. The smallest speck of fault must not willingly be allowed to
remain on the whiteness of the soul.
A certain author was about to bring out a new edition of
one of his books. He sent a copy to a number of his literary friends asking
them to read it critically and to mark every error they might find, every
blemish or infelicity in expression, and to indicate every point at which
the slightest improvement could be made. "Criticize remorselessly," he wrote
to each friend, "for I want the new edition of my book to be as near
perfection as possible." That is the way we should do with our life. No
feeling of pride should ever keep us from welcoming the revelation of any
flaw or imperfection in ourselves. Even the harsh and unkind criticisms of
enemies, we should patiently heed and consider, and if there is the smallest
ground for them—we should extract the sweet out of the bitter, for the
blessing of our own life.
No man can be his own best teacher. Exclusively self-made
men are usually very badly made. They carry most of their faults
uncorrected, lacking all the benefits of wise and faithful criticism. We
cannot be impartial judges of our own life. We cannot see clearly our own
defects and imperfections. We are charitable to our own faults.
Most of us at least have faults of which we ourselves are
entirely unaware—but which our friends and neighbors can see without
magnifying glasses. While, therefore, it requires some heroism to ask men to
tell us our own faults, he is wise who does not shrink from the friendly
scrutiny of those who wish only to do him good.
A most kindly spirit is manifested in all the letters
which have come in answer to the questions cited above. The young ladies who
write show no glee in the use of their opportunity to tell of the faults
they have seen in young men. One of them, who must be singularly fortunate
in the quality of her young gentlemen acquaintances says, "I am not able to
mention any faults." Another says, "I have come to the conclusion that
faults common to young men are few that are not just as frequently found in
young women." Still another, after mentioning several points of criticism,
says, "I think, however, that men do not have either faults or virtues
peculiar to the gender."
Yet it is evident that some young men at least have
faults even in the kindly and charitable eyes of young women. A number name
self-conceit as a too common fault. One
writes, "According to their own opinion, they have more opportunities, more
social advantages, and more brains than women." Another says, "They are
unwilling to be advised by older and more experienced people, thinking that
they know more themselves than any other person can tell them." Another
intimates that many of the young men she knows are "boastful and think more
highly of themselves than they ought to think." Another phrases it a little
differently, characterizing the fault as, "their cool self-satisfaction and
expectation of respect without any effort to make themselves particularly
admirable or worthy of respect." This writer adds, however, "I feel that you
will reply that this expectation could not exist were there not too much of
this worship paid to young men by girls."
In various forms and under various designations this same
fault is noticed by most of the writers. This indicates its commonness.
Perhaps not many of us are able to carry the consciousness of our greatness
in a modest, lowly manner, at least until we have learned the lesson amid
life's hard experiences. As men grow older the self conceit is usually taken
out of them by the buffetings and hard knocks which they receive as they
struggle on among their fellows. However, self conceit is such a blemish,
that no young man should be content to carry its mark on his life a moment
after he discovers it.
Yet this sore fault lies very close to a noble
virtue—manly self-respect, the consciousness of one's dignity and worth as a
child of God. The artist by a few touches on his picture can change a look
of haughtiness to one of humility. The change is not so easily wrought in
the character as it is on canvas—and yet it can be wrought
even there, and must be wrought, if the life is to grow into full-orbed
beauty. The only way to secure this transformation is by dwelling with all
one's littleness and imperfections, in the shadow of Christ's infinite
greatness and perfection. We will never learn it by comparing ourselves with
others who are little or no better than ourselves. But when we look at
Christ's manhood and study its perfectness, we cannot but become conscious
of our smallness and unworthiness. Nor can we ever get rid of self conceit
by merely willing to be humble and then trying to pose in the attitude of
posture of humility. The offensive element in self-conceit can be effaced
only by becoming so absorbed in noble things outside of ourselves, that we
shall altogether forget ourselves.
Another fault noticed in some young men is what one calls
"grumpiness." This writer says it is the "most common and
annoying fault of the good boys she knows," and adds, "No girl would be
allowed for a moment to be as critical, or as blunt and unsympathetic as
boys are expected to be,—good boys, home-lovers, kind-hearted, honest
Christians—but gruff and careless of their temper." This lady feels that
they are rather tyrannical in their own home, especially toward sisters and
even toward parents. Another writer hints at a like fault in the following
cluster of unlovely things growing out of one ugly root: "The most common
fault of young men is selfishness. Its name is legion; but whether called
obstinacy, love of power, love of their own comfort, tyranny, irritability,
or jealousy—the radical fault is selfishness and these faults are all
manifestations of some form of it."
Those who recognize these criticisms as just, concerning
themselves, would do well to pay good heed to the curing of the fault. It is
certainly not a quality which adorns a life. It is impossible for other
people to live with a man of such tyrannical spirit, one so impatient of
suggestion or counsel, and have any real comfort in the companionship. One
boy of this sort in a home succeeds in making a great deal of unhappiness
for those who love him best. When the evil is not cured in early years, very
unfortunate is the woman who becomes the wife of this "grumpy" man. He may
provide well for her in many ways—but he will torture if not break her
heart, by his most unmanly tyranny and his petty despotism.
Several ladies note a lack of
respect for women as a common fault. One writes, "I would mention
a lack of regard for women. A man's respect for women must begin with his
own mother." Another speaks also of a lack of thoughtful consideration and
says, "In these days old-time courtesy, true gentlemanliness is often
lacking in young men."
Another finds a common fault "in
the conduct of young men toward women." This writer divided men
into two classes—first, the pleasure-seeker, whose chief thought of life is
to get out of it all the enjoyment possible; and the second class of men,
seem to idolize a woman. To the first class, woman is a means of amusement
only; with the second, too often she is but an idol. Men of the first class
are influenced by woman's personal appearance and power to please and
gratify, regardless of her mental and moral ability. Then how many of the
second class think of woman as a comrade, a fellow-partner, or friend? They
idolize her. Both of these courses are wrong.
There is a truth here of which every young man should
think. Woman was not created for man's selfish amusement, nor was she made
to be set up on a pedestal to be worshiped. She was made to be man's
helpmeet, companion, and friend. She has her faults just as he has, and if
she is a worthy woman, she is striving just as he is to grow out of them
into perfection of character. She asks no servile homage—but only the
liberty to stand beside man as her brother, her equal. Yet the honoring of
women is always a mark of nobleness in man. Heathen men make her a slave and
degrade her. In the East a man may scarcely recognize a woman, even his own
wife or mother, in public. Christianity teaches a man, however, to look upon
woman as his equal and to treat her with deference and respect. He is not a
gentleman who can be crude in speech or act to any woman. And these writers
all say it is in companionship with his own mother and sisters that a young
man first reveals his true spirit, and in his own home that he first learns
to be respectful or disrespectful.
One writer notes "a lack of
refinement in the outward expression of life, in word and manner."
The thought is, that many young men are careless in this regard.
"They seem not to appreciate the importance of beauty and delicacy in
outward forms of life. This, I think," adds the lady "is not a little thing,
for it impacts on the ideal self the young man has in his heart." There
appears to be in some minds, at least, an impression that gentleness of
manner is effeminate, suitable for women, though not a manly grace. Some
young men affect brusqueness, even bordering on rudeness, thinking they are
cultivating a type of manliness that is to be commended. This is a mistake.
True nobleness is always beautiful. Heroic strength is always gentle. Love
is the law of life, and whatever is unlovely is a blemish. Lack of
refinement, is always a disfiguring fault. A young man may not be familiar
with the rules of etiquette, may not be able to behave gracefully in a
drawing-room; and yet he may have a grace and gentleness of heart which will
give to his bearing and acts the truest refinement.
No young man can afford to grow up without the best
culture in all lines that he can possibly get. Books cost but little, and
there usually are libraries within reach, and even those who are busy all
the day may have their evenings when they can read and study. Then the best
of all means of culture, is a gentle heart within, which inspires
thoughtfulness, consideration of others, the desire to please. The use of
art of manners to cover insincerity is the worst kind of hypocrisy. But love
in the heart ought always to have winning expression. No one can live the
thirteenth of First Corinthians and lack the truest refinement.
Many writers speak of a lack of
a worthy ambition in many young men. "Having opportunities and
abilities," says one, "they waste their lives because they fail to realize
the true object and meaning of living." Says another, "Too many of them seem
to have no grand aim, no aim higher than to dress well and be social
favorites. They have no energy to make anything of themselves." Another
names as a fault, "that love of comfort which makes them too easily
satisfied with things, if only the outward conditions are pleasant."
Another says that "young men have
time for every amusement and pleasure—but none for study and useful
reading. Many of them show little desire for self-improvement."
Several of the writers think that the young men of today are not a stalwart
type—but are in danger of becoming effeminate, indolent, not fighting the
battle of life bravely.
This is one of the perils of prosperous times when
everything is going pleasantly. A young man without enthusiastic ambition is
not worthy the sacred name of man. God did not make us to grovel like worms;
he made us to rise to glory. Every young man should strive to make all he
can of his life, and to do all he can with it. The world has neither use nor
room for men who are without energy and persistence. They can only be
dropped out and left behind while the great mass press on. No young man must
delude himself with the vain hope that his friends will look after his
success and carry him along, whether he strives or not.
This day of the world is not a time for easy-going. We
want men of noble aspiration, of unconquerable energy, of sublime hope, who
will not be contented with anything less that the best that they can make
out of their life and its opportunities. An indolent young man can never by
any mere accident of happy fortune become at mid-life a man of power and
great usefulness. People cannot dream themselves into grand
characters and lofty positions. And never was there a time when it was a
grander thing to live than now, when true men have larger opportunity to do
noble deeds and make a worthy record for themselves. They know not what they
say—who speak of the time for heroisms and valiant deeds and fine
achievements, as in the past.
Many of my friends have spoken of a
lack of courage as another too common fault in young men.
"They fear to unite with the church," writes one, "not because they do not
recognize the duty and feel the need of so doing—but because they dread the
taunts and sneers of companions." Others speak of the same lack shown by too
many in yielding to soul-destroying temptation in the face of their own
convictions, simply because they have not the courage to stem the tide of
social custom. This is the way thousands of drunkards are made. Young
men do not intend to drink—but the temptation comes upon them through
companions, with sneer and scorn at their scruples, and in weakness they
yield, thus losing in the battle of life because they are not brave enough
to say "no". A man without courage—is a man at the mercy of all evil.
Many writers have their anxious words concerning the
frequent falling of young men into the grosser
vices and sins. The evils which surround the saloon and
card-table are named among the dangers. One says, "Our boys are drifting.
Street-corner crowds, cigar stores, cards and, lastly, saloons, have one by
one thrown their nets around them. They were only having a little fun,
they said. Boys can't stay in the house all the time. We will come out
all right. Poor, foolish boys!" Another names "Their associating with
companions whose character is questionable." Another mentions "Swearing,
intemperance, betting, lying." Another says, "They are too fond of gaiety,
the social glass, and card-playing."
There is something so debasing in the grosser vices to
which many permit themselves to become addicted, that one would think that
no noble young man with clean hands, a pure heart, and an unsullied life,
would ever stoop to indulge in them even for a moment. Yet "many of them
think it manly to be able to say that they can drink intoxicating liquors,
swear, and run into other defiling things," writes one of my correspondents.
What a sad travesty on manliness! What a desecration of God-like beauty!
What a pity it is that so many young men with splendid natural abilities,
capable of great things, should so fling away their birthright! Why should
not the obligations of sobriety, of reverence, of purity, rest with as holy
sanction upon young men as upon young women? One writer asks, "Why should
not young men be as pure and modest as young girls?" Says another, "If I
were to marry, I would want my husband every bit as good as myself. I
recognize no law of self-respect incumbent upon one and not upon the other."
These words ought not to be lost upon young men who read
them. Why indeed should any young man demand that his sister, or the young
woman he makes his friend, shall live after a rule of almost angelic purity,
above suspicion, free from the slightest taint—while he refuses to bring his
own life and conduct under the same rule? Does our Lord's beatitude for
purity mean one thing for a young man and something a great deal loftier and
whiter for a young woman? No! whatever is a stain upon true womanliness is
just as dark a stain upon ideal manhood.
So much for the "faults" of young men, which some of
their fair friends have pointed out. It is not implied in these words, which
seem to be critical, that there are not many noble and beautiful qualities
in the young men in whom some faults have been seen. On the other hand,
there are thousands of young men whose lives are rich in the elements of
truest manliness, whose characters are radiant with the luster of "whatever
things are honorable," and who are making for themselves records worthy of
all praise. This is the golden age of young men. The faults that are here
noted are lesser or greater blemishes on noble lives, pointed out in
sincerest friendship, in the hope that by correction them these lives shall
rise to still fairer beauty and yet manlier strength.
It is more pleasant to
look on this side of the subject than at the faults. It is better to try to
build up than to tear down. It is here that the chief pressure of living
should be exercised. While we must not be blind to our faults and
imperfections, the best way to deal with them usually is not to try to
remedy them one by one—but to seek larger abundance of life, thus expelling
them—by the power of new affections. There are many physical weaknesses and
ailments which can better be overcome, not by treating them as diseases
requiring medicines—but by seeking to gain grater fullness of health.
Without doubt, the true method in the culture of character, is not to give
too much thought directly to one's defects and faults—but to seek to have
the heart-life pure, strong, and full—so that it will throw off the
blemishes and flaws, and fill up what is lacking in the outer life.
2. Name some of the qualities and elements of character, which you regard as
essential in the IDEAL of young manhood.
What are the qualities and elements of character in the
true ideal of young manhood? Nearly every reply suggests
honesty, integrity, truthfulness, as
among the foundation elements in manly life. One enumerates "honesty,
truthfulness, and courage to do right though opposed by friends. Another
specifies "truthfulness, reliability." Another says "Integrity seems to be
the foundation of all that is high in character." Another's ideal is, "One
who has the courage to say NO, when he needs to, and when he ought
to say it."
So it is made plain in almost every letter that the ideal
of manliness in the minds of these thoughtful young women includes the
sturdy qualities of splendid integrity, unflinching uprightness, and
undeviating truthfulness. It is needful in these days to put strong emphasis
upon this side of a noble life. Many of what are esteemed successful careers
altogether lacks these robust elements. But worldly success is not life's
final test. Even among men no character long shines out clear and bright,
with honor and beauty—which has not for its central principle simple
integrity. Says Lord Lytton, "A man is already of consequence in the world
when it is known that he can be implicitly relied upon." And George
MacDonald says, speaking of the influence of a good life in the world, "To
know one person that is absolutely to be trusted will do more for a man's
moral nature,—yes, and even for his spiritual nature, than will all the
sermons he ever heard or ever can hear." To be able to build up such a
character, to live so as to be implicitly relied upon, absolutely trusted by
those who know him, certainly is an object in life worthy of any young man's
striving to obtain.
It takes years of unfailing fidelity to reach such a
point. No such name can be won in a community in a day. One dishonest act,
one deviation from perfect integrity, one failure in moral obligation—will
dim the luster of a name. Carelessness may do it. There are men, for
example, who continually borrow little sums of money from others and forget
that they owe them—let us charitably say they "forget" to pay them. There
are men who are negligent about keeping promises and appointments. However
good in other regards the men who thus habitually fail may be—it is
impossible that they can come to be implicitly relied upon. Forgetfulness
and carelessness are habits which bring many a man to ruin.
Perfect integrity! Write the words on your very soul. No manhood can be
really noble which does not possess this heroic quality.
Many of the letters emphasize also the
gentle side of manliness. "The union of
gentleness of manner—with firmness of mind." "He must have true politeness,
which treats everyone kindly." "One who can be nearly as gentle as a
woman—and yet be a manly man." "Loving and thoughtful toward parents and
friends, with a shining face, cordial and kindly." "Gentle, loving, true,
pure, with all that is good, kindly and unselfish." "He must be brave as a
lion—and gentle as a woman." "Kind and respectful to everyone, and never
cruel even to the least of God's creatures." So in nearly all the letters
this gentle-heartedness is seen to shine in the ideal close alongside the
robuster elements as equally essential. "He keeps his temper under control,"
writes one, "is generous, courteous, kind, and, above all, unselfish. I
would tremble to trust my life to a selfish man."
It is often said of Jesus, the only perfect man the world
ever saw, that both the manly and womanly virtues were found in him. We know
how brave and true and strong he was, and we know also how gentle he was.
Behold in him the ideal manhood. No manly character is complete which lacks
affectionateness and tender-heartedness. Strength without this human quality
is not beautiful. Several writers refer to Paul's wonderful picture of noble
Christian life: "Whatever things are true, whatever things are honorable,
whatever things are just, whatever things are pure, whatever things are
lovely, and whatever things are of good report." Here we have gentleness as
well as strength in "whatever things are lovely," linked with whatever
things are true."
Many incidents are related of great men, showing the
kindly side of their character. One may be given an illustration. It is of
Mr. Corliss, the great engine-builder. He was about erecting an addition to
his shops, and it was necessary to remove a ledge of rock by blasting. As
the work progressed, a bird's nest was discovered in a crevice of the rock
which the men were about to remove. "That nest will have to go," said the
foreman to Mr. Corliss, pointing to the place where the robin was sitting.
The two men drew near, and as the mother-bird flew away they saw five little
blue eggs in the nest. Mr. Corliss found that the nest could not be moved
without destroying it, and he gave orders, therefore, that the work of
removing the rock should stop until the robin had hatched out her young, and
until they were old enough to fly away. So the great engine-builder's
interests waited while the robin sat quietly on her nest, with an air of
vast importance, as if she were queen of a realm. This incident shows the
gentle side of this man's character, and who will say it is not beautiful,
the very adornment of his manhood?
Purity is named by many of the writers as
another quality in the ideal young manhood. Writes one, "The man-soul should
be as unsullied and white as the woman soul. Does not purity cover
all—purity in thought, in word, in deed?" Another says, referring to the
same point: "There is no reason why young men should not be held to as high
a standard of character as their sisters." Another puts it thus: "The
indispensable quality is reverence for all humanity and all natural and
right relations." This lady gives an example—an artist who has had many
years of Bohemian artist life, has seen every temptation, "And he is just as
good and gentle as ever. I cannot imagine an ill thought ever entering his
mind. His wife is a happy woman, and not one of his pupils and models can
fail to be inspired by him to purer purpose and higher ideals. I cannot see
why the virtues should be of different genders. I know of none that are not
equally beautiful in man and in woman."
Jesus himself said, "Blessed are the pure in heart; for
they shall see God." An Apostle gave it as an essential in a holy life, that
we keep ourselves "unspotted from the world."
Energy is another quality that is mentioned by
these writers. One speaks of "perseverance," another of "strength," another
of "proper ambition," while many use the word "energy" to express their
thought. Evidently, thoughtful young women want to see young men make
something of their life. They have little patience with indolence and little
respect for a man who will not work with energy and a purpose.
Some men who never get on in life, blame their failure on
their unfavorable circumstances. They think if their condition had only been
different they would have been successful. But the way to make the most of
life is not to get easy conditions; it is to take the conditions we have—and
by energy, faithfulness, indomitable courage, and unsparing, unrelaxing
toil, to make our conditions and circumstances serve us in doing the work of
life well and in building up a noble character.
Without exception these letters name among the elements
of the ideal young manhood—true religion, faith in Christ, and loyalty to
him. "My ideal man is first a Christian," says one. "A Christian like young
man will, little by little, become like the one he is following, and will
copy the qualities of his Master." "A Christian who takes Christ into his
business, his pleasures, and into every part of his life." "Strength of
character to stand up for Christ and be right." "There is but one pattern
for us all to follow, and therefore the man who follows it most closely is
nearest to perfection." Thus the letters run, putting
love to Christ as the crown of all noble manhood.
It is in Christ alone, that we find the true ideal of
manliness realized. He is the one only perfect Man, without sin or
imperfection, who though tempted in all points like as we are, yet yielded
not. Also, it is in the divine Christ alone, that we can receive the life
and grace we need, to enable us to rise into the noble ideal of manhood
which he himself has set before us.
So much for the ideal of manhood. There is in the soul of
every true-hearted and worthy young man, a vision of beauty and nobleness
which he himself earnestly desires to attain. It is radiant and without
spot. Someone says, "God never yet permitted us to frame a theory too
beautiful for his power to make practicable." A fair vision cannot be
realized in a day—it is the work of a whole lifetime to attain it; yet it
should be kept before the eye all the time, and the effort to come up to it
should never faint nor lag for an instant. Through all experiences, through
trial, temptation, discouragement, opposition, defeat, and failure, and
through all changes of circumstances and conditions—the eye should rest
unwaveringly upon the goal, and the purpose to gain it should never be
abandoned. Every day should mark progress. That only is true living,
which is ever learning, ever reaching upward and stretching forward. The
heart is dead, which has ceased to throb with longing for something yet
better, and the hand is derelict in its duty which has slacked in its
working. The goal ever lies onward. We must live and die learning, striving.
We need enthusiasm. No life ever reached anything very beautiful, radiant,
noble, and worthy—without this fire of God burning at its heart.
Then we must not forget that only God himself can make
possible and practicable, the realizing of our vision of manhood. A young
man must never leave God out of his life. He ever needs divine inspiration
and help. It is God who sets before him the radiant vision which he would
attain, and it is God alone who can help him to fill out the fair pattern
divinely shown to him in the Mount.